Ewch i’r prif gynnwys

Dr Derek Lang

Lecturers,School of English, Communication and Philosophy

Published 26 Oct 2018 • 30 mins read

icon1 recommendations Download Download

Using a mock legal trial to debate a controversial subject

This is a downloadable report on the outcomes of a project investigating the role of peer-assessment and feedback.

PROJECT DESCRIPTION & METHODOLOGY

There is an apparent tension between the indicative workload limit for assessment and feedback (one hour per student, per module) and the diversity and quality of feedback the University aims to give. A common suggestion is to make use of peer feedback. Anecdotal evidence suggests peer feedback is positively received in some disciplines, yet underutilised or unpopular in others. This pilot study starts to explore the conditions under which peer feedback works (or doesn’t), identifies some of the particular factors and circumstances affecting its reception by students, and suggests ways to remove barriers to its successful implementation. The project focussed mostly on Philosophy, but we anticipate the findings will have wider application.

The project’s overarching aims were three-fold:

1. To trial different opportunities for, and kinds of, peer feedback.

2. To gather qualitative and quantitative data on the perceived usefulness of peer feedback, before, during, and after interventions (see below).

3. To improve students’ ability to identify and utilise different kinds of feedback (including, but not limited to, peer feedback).

Ultimately, we wished to improve the perception of peer feedback among students by helping them to understand its usefulness, identify the conditions under which it is most valuable, and gain insight into the barriers that can hinder its success.

To achieve these outcomes, we set three specific objectives:

  1. a. Canvas opinion among undergraduates concerning peer feedback (gathering both qualitative and quantitative data) – see §1.1.
  2. b. Trial six interventions across three modules in philosophy (two undergraduate and one postgraduate module) – see §1.2.
  3. c. Measure the difference in perceived usefulness between the different interventions, including instances identified explicitly as constituting peer feedback versus those described merely in terms of the activity (e.g. ‘a group exercise’) – see §2f.

Please download to see the full report

Download Download

You might also be interested in:

Flip the Familiar

Mrs Rosemary Smith

Published 19 Apr 2017 • 20 mins read

A presentation from Rosemary Smith of Cardiff Business School on how she flipped her classrooms in a unique way to help develop students' academic and professional potential.


Topics

Flipping the classroom

icon0 recommendations

Flip the Familiar

Mrs Rosemary Smith

Published 19 Apr 2017 • 20 mins read

A presentation from Rosemary Smith of Cardiff Business School on how she flipped her classrooms in a unique way to help develop students' academic and professional potential.


Topics

Flipping the classroom

icon0 recommendations

Flipping the Classroom - Video Case Study

Dr Stephen Rutherford

Published 17 Feb 2017 • 5 minutes read

A short case study from Dr Rutherford outlining his experiences of 'flipping the classroom' within his modules.


Topics

Flipping the classroom | Delivering lectures |

icon1 recommendations

Flipping the Classroom - Video Case Study

Dr Stephen Rutherford

Published 17 Feb 2017 • 5 minutes read

A short case study from Dr Rutherford outlining his experiences of 'flipping the classroom' within his modules


Topics

Flipping the classroom | Delivering lectures |

icon1 recommendations

Using personal capture for Flipped Learning

Dr Kate Gilliver

Published 09 May 2017 • 5 minutes read

A short case study from Dr Rutherford outlining his experiences of 'flipping the classroom' within his modules


Topics

Flipping the classroom | Large group teaching | Delivering lectures |

icon3 recommendations

Using personal capture for Flipped Learning

Dr Kate Gilliver

Published 09 May 2017 • 10 mins read

A case study from Dr Gilliver and her students on how she flipped her classroom using Panopto's personal capture capabilities.


Topics

Flipping the classroom | Large group teaching | Delivering lectures |

icon3 recommendations

Cyfrannu at yr Hwb Dysgu

Mae'r Hwb Dysgu wedi ei greu gan academyddion i academyddion, ac rydym yn eich annog chi i rannu unrhyw beth sydd yn cefnogi, amlygu neu adlewyrchu ar dysgu ac addysgu yma ym Mhrifysgol Caerdydd.

Mae hwn yn gyfle i gymryd rhan weithredol o'r gymuned ddysgu yng Nghaerdydd, i rannu eich arbenigedd gyda'ch cyd-weithwyr.