‘Goodbye to all that? A critical re-evaluation of the role of the high performance work organisation within the UK skills debate’
Caroline Lloyd and Jonathan Payne
A number of commentators involved with the UK policy debate on skills have recently argued in favour of an active role for government in helping to diffuse the model of the high performance work organisation (HPWO). More specifically, the HPWO is said to offer an environment in which skills and knowledge can be developed on a continuous basis and utilised to full effect. For these commentators, part of the model's attraction lies in its potential to shift the current policy debate beyond its narrow emphasis on boosting the supply of skills and qualifications as the main route to developing a high skills economy in the UK. This article argues that there has been a tendency for academics from the vocational education and training community to 'buy into' the high performance work model too uncritically without interrogating its key assumptions. A closer engagement with the critical literature surrounding the HPWO suggests that its implications for skills and employees are uncertain and may, in some cases, be negative. We question, therefore, whether the HPWO should be seen as a suitable vehicle for a high skills project in the UK and ask whether it might be time to re-focus attention on the more fundamental issue of how to develop high skilled, high quality employment whilst also improving work and employment conditions for employees in general.
A longer version of this article was published as a SKOPE working paper in 2004.
Lloyd, C. and Payne, J. (2004) ‘‘Idle fancy’’ or ‘concrete will’? Defining and realizing a high skills vision for the UK’, SKOPE Research Paper, No 47.
A practitioner-orientated SKOPE Issues paper is also available that provides a brief overview of the key arguments.
Lloyd, C and Payne, P. (2005), ‘High performance work organisation - A driver for the high skills vision?’, SKOPE Issues Paper, No. 6.
A range of academic and practitioner perspectives on the high performance work organisation can be found in the February 2007 edition of UKWON (UK Work Organisation Network) Journal, published by the Involvement and Participation Association.